{Put This One on Your TBR List}
Book Review: Middle of
the Night by Riley Sager
by Karen S. Wiesner

Be aware that there may be spoilers in this review.
Middle of the Night by Riley Sager is his latest novel, published in June 2024. In this story, the main character Ethan Marsh is still haunted 30 years later by the disappearance of his best friend Billy from the tent in the backyard they were camping out in at the age of ten. When Ethan woke in the morning, Billy was gone, the roof of the tent slashed. Billy was never seen again. Now, as a 40 year old, Ethan returns to the New Jersey cul de sac Hemlock Circle, where it seems Billy is trying to get his attention, maybe from beyond the grave. In this place, then and now, nothing is as it seems--least of all those who populate the area.
As usual, this novel skirts the
line between horror and the supernatural, which I love in my fiction. However,
all my usual complaints (when it comes to a Sager story) are here--and in ample
supply. First, the book was a good 150 pages longer than I believe was actually
necessary. Also, there were far too many characters to keep track of and for
the author to flesh out adequately--which, I know, is what's wanted in this
niche genre (made popular by Gillian Flynn, Paula Hawkins, S.J. Watson, and
Sager himself, among others) where the narrator of any given story simply can't
be trusted to tell his or her own story with any degree of veracity. Sager
upped my stress level by telling Middle
of the Night from the entire cast of characters' point of views within this
book. I've read four of his eight available titles written under this pen name,
and thus far he usually keeps it to a single POV within a story. So now I had
to juggle a whole host of suspicious people doing disturbing things, all
sporting their own nefarious motives.
Now when most people read psychological thrillers, they know to expect unreliable narrators, unexpected plot twists, and featuring characters who are not only complex but usually also liars (to themselves and everyone around them). That's the name of the game. If you like that kind of story, there's no reason you wouldn't love this book. It's got all of that and you won't ever feel entirely sure who's the culprit while reading.
Despite that the tension was aplenty within this tale, my pet peeves about Sager's works became overkill. Even for Sager, the sheer number of characters and viewpoints, the overabundance of motives--certainty developed far more than the individual characters were--all packed into this weighty 365 page book (hardcover) left me weary. The more I read books like this, the more I don't like and trust the author. I felt overwhelmed by all the characters, all of whom seemed guilty of something, their half-truths and skewed perceptions. What really cinched it for me was that one of the characters in the book was barely mentioned the entire length of the story until the end. When he was pulled like a chicken (instead of the expected rabbit) from a hat, all my hackles rose and I cried "Unfair! Cheater!"
For the most part, usually I believe this author has played fair with readers--if we're really paying attention from one page to the next--we can't deny that the answers were all there, buried deep in multiple levels of deceptions on everyone's parts. Here, I argue that we weren't given the information we needed to make the leap. Or maybe the book was just too long and convoluted and I missed that vital bit. Who knows? For me, neither the ghostly aspects nor the shocking, twisted denouement could save this story, let alone top his previous endeavors. Ultimately, Middle of the Night did receive more than fair reviews elsewhere, so if this is your usual type of suspense, you may end up much more satisfied by it than I ultimately was.
Karen Wiesner is an award-winning, multi-genre
author of over 150 titles and 16 series.
Visit her website here: https://karenwiesner.weebly.com/
and https://karenwiesner.weebly.com/karens-quill-blog
Find out more about her books and see her art
here: http://www.facebook.com/KarenWiesnerAuthor
Visit her publisher here: https://www.writers-exchange.com/Karen-Wiesner/