Showing posts with label Karen Wiesner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Karen Wiesner. Show all posts

Friday, November 13, 2026

{Put This One on Your TBR List} Book Review: Astarion (Baldur's Gate III) by T. Kingfisher by Karen S. Wiesner

 

{Put This One on Your TBR List} Book Review:

Astarion (Baldur's Gate III) by T. Kingfisher

by Karen S. Wiesner 

 

My mother taught me that, if I can't say something nice, then don't say anything at all. This philosophy has always been my guideline in reviewing. Only infrequently have I posted a review that wasn't basically positive. For that reason, I wasn't going to review Astarion after I read it. However, I was specifically asked to provide my perspective on the novel given my passing familiarity with Baldur's Gate as well as the Dungeons & Dragons/Forgotten Realms franchise. That said, I advise that everyone take what I say here with a grain of salt and to be aware that I don't believe Astarion was poorly written in the least. It simply wasn't something I enjoyed (others have and will appreciate it in varying degrees). Throughout this overview, combined with my review of the novel, I'll explain why I personally felt so let-down by Kingfisher's prequel novelization that includes the character Astarion's backstory. 

To start with, I'll say that I read Astarion for two reasons: 1) I read everything T. Kingfisher writes, so this was a given, and 2) because I have some experience with playing the Baldur's Gate videogame series (though I will say I probably wouldn't have read the book at all if it hadn't been written by this particular author). 

My first true foray into this universe was R. A. Salvatore's The Dark Elf Trilogy (read my review here: https://aliendjinnromances.blogspot.com/2023/07/book-review-dark-elf-trilogy-by-ra.html) which featured the dark drow character of Drizzt Do'Urden and the Underdark setting in Menzoberranzan. In this place, cunning, scheming, and unscrupulous politics are the order of the day. There is no room for honor, love, or even friendship. Drizzt was born into this horrible (though fascinating) place. One of the biggest reasons I was so amazed by this trilogy was that, in normal stories, good characters are in a place where basically good is done and expected by all, and then a villain enters and disrupts that equilibrium. But, in The Dark Elf Trilogy, we have a good character surrounded by the worst kind of evil, in a location where all of society and its attitude is centered on cut-throat survival of the fittest. Drizzt is different. He's selfless and heroic. I've read several other miniseries under the Drizzt umbrella, but nothing else that topped it when it comes to utterly captivating me. 

Beyond that, my daughter bought me a copy of both Baldur's Gate I and II Enhanced in one physical package in 2020, I think. At that time, through tenacity, I was able to play both of these games back-to-back. I remember enjoying them very much, though at this time I recall little or nothing about them beyond that the gameplay was incredibly convoluted and not in the least intuitive. I powered through, nevertheless, because I was very interested in the setting they took place in after having read The Dark Elf Trilogy. Also, I fell into a rhythm that allowed me to be able to flourish in completing the games. However, when I attempted to return for a second play-through about a year later, I couldn't get the hang of the weird gameplay, and therefore wasn't able to play them again. (I'm not alone in this situation. Others I've talked to have also said that they always forget how to play the game between playthroughs.) 

Fast-forward several years later. My nephew learned I'd played the first two games, so upon its release he secured a deluxe edition of Balder's Gate III that came with a physical copy of the game and double soundtrack (which is absolutely stunning and made the shocking price for this edition well-worth it), posters and miscellaneous memorabilia. [Note for those unfamiliar with the series or videogames that BG III is the one that the character Astarion made his first appearance in.] 

I started the videogame with high hopes, but I instantly disliked many things about it. I don't know how else to describe this, but the game is presented in a "fish-eyed" manner with oddball control schemes and camera angles. Everything is almost microscopically tiny, and you're viewing a massive setting through miniscule eyes, causing you as the main character to feel off-balanced, dizzy, and almost ludicrously small. All this makes it almost impossible to see anything with any degree of clarity in this fishbowl of a world. Also, the subtitles were clearly intended for people who can read smaller-than-normal print, and therefore I wasn't able to catch contextual clues without having my face pressed up against the TV monitor at all times. If you've played the game and haven't experienced this, I expect it's because you're young and have good eyesight. Additionally, the combat style in III is the old, horrible kind that's turn-based, dice-roll determination--you know, how battles were fought before videogames got really good, fun, and easy to play, especially for older people like me! Before and during my initial time playing this videogame, I read multiple game guides and searched online for some clue how to do anything by way of engaging in battle. I didn't understand the mechanics, nor did anyone want to explain it. In lieu of direction, I was invariably treated to barely veiled, contemptuous implications that I was a moron because I didn't get it and they wouldn't lower themselves by explaining it. 

After countless, needless deaths, I turned to my husband, who tried to fight the battle for me but gave up almost immediately. You know a videogame is too hard and complicated when you're only in the first few minutes of gameplay, you're playing on story mode (which is easier than easy), and yet you can't win a battle to save your life. Weeks or months later, I can't remember, my daughter (who considers the combat in this game boring) played some of it and got me a little further along in the battle, but I still wasn't able to complete it on my own. At last another nephew finished that combat for me, but I was exhausted trying to learn that much and felt defeated. That final time, I actually escaped the ship and was in the wider world with my new companions that I'd rescued from the mind flayer's ship (picking up Astarion just after the getaway). I couldn't go any further. I was too discouraged by how hard this initial portion of the game was to want to induce more trauma on myself. That's as far as I ever got in BG III. I do want to try again in the future because I believe the story might be rewarding enough to put up with the stupidity of the difficult gameplay and visuals. I'm not optimistic that it'll go any better, but we'll see. 

Note that BG I and II are connected--you play as the same character with many of the same companions. Shortly after the events of I, II begins. Novelizations of the games were also made available by various authors, including Drew Karpyshyn, who was involved in my favorite franchise Mass Effect. Game I included much less complex characters and conflicts than game II, with developers taking into account the "constructive criticism" of I's players. III takes place a hundred years after the events of II and features more complicated characters and conflicts. In the opening scene, the primary character you play as is imprisoned on board an illithid (mind flayer) ship, which crashes, and you're intended to rescue several prisoners who become recruitable companions, depending on dialogue and actions. All have been infected with a parasite. Without a cure, transformation into a mind flayer is certain. That's the gist of the game. Almost all the infected characters want to be rid of "the tadpole", but Astarion is the exception to this for complicated reasons that are discovered during the course of gameplay. 

High Elf Astarion Ancunin can either be a protagonist or a recruitable party member in the game, as the player sees fit. He's a rogue and a vampire spawn--not a full vampire, since in this fictional world, vampires are very powerful and this didn't fit his character development, according to the senior writer, Stephen Rooney, who created him. Before being made into a vampire spawn by Cazador Szarr, Astarion was a magistrate who loved decadence and was an unrepentant hedonist. While he might consider himself just, the fact was, he was manipulative and dedicated to his own aims. Always. His own pleasure and advancement are at the core of his being. Becoming a vampire thrall didn't change him so much as refine his original modus operandi of being free and answerable only to himself. Morality isn't a goal or even of any interest to him within Astarion the novel--and everything I've read leads me to suspect it isn't in the BG III videogame either. However, the basis of most modern videogames is, of course, that your choices influence the character you're controlling as well as your party members. So it is entirely possible that Astarion could be persuaded to redeem himself if your decisions resonate with him throughout the game. That said, everything I've read, including the 400-page official game guide, convinces me that true morality isn't something he'll ever achieve, nor will he desire to. 

T. Kingfisher's prequel to Astarion's character has the story shifting between Astarion's early days as a working-class boy taken in by rich relatives to his present life as Cazador's slave. While it's true that Astarion (along with many other unfortunates) has endured centuries of mental and physical torture at the hands of a cruel master and the reader isn't immune to feeling shocked and horrified, Astarion is portrayed as possessing with little by way of squeamishness let alone true deep trauma. Kingfisher's infatuation with the character simply won't allow that. As such, he has no trouble performing whatever acts Szarr requires of him, though he'd clearly rather be off doing life on his own terms. Who Astarion was all through his youth and into adulthood, as well as into his thrawn years, isn't all that much different…save for the fact that he isn't his own master and he's forced to do things that aren't his choice. He would have been the same person regardless of what direction his life might have taken him. It's who he is and, even being under the relentless and bottomless abuse of an evil master doesn't and can't change him. His quest in this book is undertaken solely as an attempt to free himself and become his own boss. Not unexpected or even uncommon. But I wanted more--much more altruism, loads less self-centeredness. 

From start to finish, Astarion might be seen as a charming rogue, but he wasn't one who drew my sympathy or, more importantly, my respect at any point. As such, readers are shown almost no true character growth in Kingfisher's story as a direct result of the author having her hands tied. She agreed to that. She eagerly undertook the project, being a massive fan of BG III, which she's played many times and feels she knows the characters and world extremely well, certainly enough to undertake a prequel of one of its most lauded characters. She was given direction by the Wizards of the Coast developmental team as well as others associated with this character, but ultimately she had to play in their sandbox and follow the canon as she was directed to. The result of that situation means that, in Astarion's precursor story, his growth and arc, including the resolution, could never come to fruition, as all of those things are developed and concluded in the BG III game. In other words, anything that comes before BG III had to fit into the mold of the future events in the videogame. Kingfisher is brave and bold to do this, and (my dislike of the book notwithstanding) I believe she was the perfect person to write the story. Her The World of the White Rat stories all align very closely to this and D&D in general. Unfortunately for me, anything she did with this story would have had to be disappointing to me because I need authentic character arc progression and a satisfactory redemption resolution. In reading the basics of Astarion's within the videogame, I've discovered there are two outcomes for him in BG III--power that turns him into an unredeemable monster or love (with the character you're playing as) allowing him to go along with your decisions but never actually bringing him to full absolution. 

My introduction to a high elf in this universe was Drizzt. Drizzt is noble, complex, and ever-evolving. Quite simply, Astarion is not. Drizzt had countless experiences that tested him and could have turned him into a monster, but he ultimately took the high road. Astarion was the opposite of Drizzt. Astarion had no drive to redeem himself in a way that I could get on board with. He wanted to be free to indulge himself, not to selflessly help others. He didn't care to make the world better, only to make his own world better for himself. Yes, he may be persuaded by your BG III character to support--nothing more, nothing less--you, but that's the extent of it. Deep down, he was and always will be selfish, sightless, and extremely unappealing to someone like me. I believe only a reader who's wholly unfamiliar with the character of Drizzt in this wide universe would find Astarion anything but boring, superficial, immoral, and unworthy of being rooted for. Harsh, I know. Apologies. Recall that I wasn't going to post my review of the book, and I'm a bit uncomfortable doing so like this in a public setting. 

Do I think the book Kingfisher wrote is bad? No. If I'd finished playing BG III, I might have found myself seduced by this character, the way the author clearly is. But, having only read her book, I was mainly just disgusted by him. Also, while Kingfisher does write for children and young adults, for the most part even her adult fiction is PG-13. I wasn't prepared for the language and shocking nastiness of this novel at all. That aspect made it very difficult for me to finish reading. That said, I'm sure she's written nothing that hasn't been done before in the universe. My experience, however, has mainly been with the heroics of Drizzt and friends and Salvatore's "suitable for children" adult adventures. Bottom line, I found this character to be a poor man's Drizzt, not worth my time or notice. But that's just my opinion. I fully expect a lot of people will like him and enjoy this book, especially those who have played the game. 

To wrap this up, I'll mention that HBO may be developing a TV series of BG III. I'd certainly watch it to get the story in BG III without having to try to play the impossible game. 

Karen Wiesner is an award-winning, multi-genre author of 156 titles and 16 series. Visit her website here: https://www.writers-exchange.com/Karen-Wiesner/

Friday, November 06, 2026

{Put This One on Your TBR List} Book Review The World of the White Rat: Daggerbound, Book 2 of Swordheart by T. Kingfisher by Karen S. Wiesner

 

{Put This One on Your TBR List} Book Review

The World of the White Rat: Daggerbound, Book 2 of Swordheart

by T. Kingfisher

by Karen S. Wiesner

 

It's always a treat to return to T. Kingfisher's The World of the White Rat, an umbrella that covers many connected series. Do a search here on the Alien Romances blog to find reviews associated with this universe. Given that there's a lot already written and available, you might be wondering where to get started. I'll point out that, prior to this new release, the author suggested that the best order to read these books in was the same as the publication order. That may or may not remain the case, but it's easy to assume the story here takes place not too long after the events of Swordheart. For convenience, here's my list of The World of the White Rat universe offerings: 

Clocktaur War

Clockwork Boys, Book 1 (November 2017)

The Wonder Engine, Book 2 (July 2018)      

 

Swordheart

Swordheart, Book 1 (November 2018)

Daggerbound, Book 2 (August 2026 and this tale may actually take place later--after The Saint of Steel books, but there's no way to be sure)

Shieldborn, Book 3 (coming August 2027 and again it's hard to know what order it will fit in with the other series books)

 

The Saint of Steel

Paladin's Grace, Book 1 (February 2020)   

Paladin's Strength, Book 2 (February 2021)            

Paladin's Hope, Book 3 (October 2021)       

Paladin's Faith, Book 4 (December 2023) 

 

On her Red Wombat Studio website, the author stated that "there are seven books planned in the Saint of Steel series!" but the fact that Daggerbound (among other new and upcoming releases) aren't listed on it at all tells me it's not kept especially up-to-date. As such, Saint of Steel may or may not be getting anything new in the future. 

Kingfisher's medieval romances are anything but ordinary. While I had a few minor issues with Swordheart, for the most part I enjoyed it immensely, so I was eager to read whatever followed. At the time of my previous review for the first book in the series, the fate of the last two weren't decided yet. The author spoke about wanting to write the stories of the others cursed to be bound to a weapon but that she "had a lot of trouble getting the Dervish's story to come out". She clearly did figure it out, but I believe she originally intended Daggerbound to be the third in the trilogy instead of the second. No matter. 

In the newest installment, we revisit the enchanting medieval world all the other stories are set in and find Learned Edmund--featured in the Clockwork stories--tasked to transport another sword relic from one temple to another. Little does anyone realize that he's decided to be done with this frustrating profession. He intends to take the stubborn mule he's given for transport, drop off the relic, and forever wave sayonara to the order he's given his life to up to this point. Along the way, he's attacked by bandits. Unthinkingly, he grabs the sword to protect it from harm, and, lo and behold, out pops what he believes to be a hunky angel. In actuality, the Dervish is anything but. He's an immortal warrior trapped in the sword, and he is not happy about it one bit. He's never felt anything but outright scorn for the previous wielders of the sword. Edmund is vastly different than any of them. As a result, the Dervish finds a protective side of himself he never realized he had. 

This story is, at turns, hilarious, suspenseful, poignant, and compelling. Populated with a host of new and old, complex characters that are human, insect, and animal (including another lovable gnole!), the world expands and contracts accordingly as the gang travels nonstop through plenty of adventures and unexpected high jinks. Beware! There's a menacing dragon lurking on these pages. Huzzah! I loved that the author brought us back around to meet up with the previous group of characters--Halla and Sarkis and their equally unusual troupe--so we can see what's become of them and their happily ever after. In the process, Kingfisher also dropped a few hints about Sarkis and the Dervish's female companion, Angharad Shieldborn, bound in the third cursed sword, getting us eager for the final volume in the trilogy. 

An insightful Goodreads reviewer perfectly summed up how satisfying this story is with the words, "smart, character-driven, emotionally grounded, and just a little bit weird". What's not to love? T. Kingfisher usually delivers a rollicking good tale, and Daggerbound is no exception. If you haven't read anything in this universe, or something else by this author, it's long past time to jump in and join the fun. 

Karen Wiesner is an award-winning, multi-genre author of 156 titles and 16 series. Visit her website here: https://www.writers-exchange.com/Karen-Wiesner/

Friday, October 23, 2026

{Put This One on Your TBR List}: Review of A Botanical Daughter by Noah Medlock Accompanied by Karen Wiesner's Original Artwork by Karen S. Wiesner

 

{Put This One on Your TBR List}:

Review of A Botanical Daughter by Noah Medlock

Accompanied by Karen Wiesner's Original Artwork

by Karen S. Wiesner 

  Beware spoilers! 

I was looking for something to read on my Libby library app, and A Botanical Daughter by Noah Medlock came up, no doubt because of my newfound love of gardening and horror literature. This 2024 Victorian gothic chiller was the author's first book. The basic story is two Victorian-age, quirky gentlemen live a cloistered existence in an equally eccentric botanical garden. Simon is a taxidermist who views his usually whimsical (i.e., not disturbing) craft as art. Gregor is a celebrated, though somewhat spurned, horticulturist whose greatest love is cultivating wildly exotic plants. His latest acquisition is a strange fungus he's convinced is capable of unprecedented intelligence. He's determined to make it his masterpiece. Throw in a spirited housemaid named Jennifer who's a bit of an oddity herself in the community they live, and readers are treated to a whole menagerie of curiosities to explore. Jennifer has recently lost the friend she loves, one she believes was murdered by her own father, though she has no way to prove it. 

This story began in a wonderfully witty, charming way that captured me instantly, especially when the story turned into a gardener's version of Frankenstein. Seriously, what more could you want? I was mesmerized with the wonderful characters and their irresistible setting. Jennifer was unexpectedly vibrant, not willing to be defined by those around her, and fiercely true to herself and her values. Simon and Gregor were at first alike only in that both displayed erratic artist temperaments, yet the author made them very unique…at least initially. 

The first half of this book was amazing. I enjoyed every word, all the unorthodox developments, the author's clever turns of phrase that had me laughing out loud from one page to the next. I wanted to include at least one or two of the best of those gems here but my library app took the ebook back too quickly. 

Despite such a winning start, the last half of the story, regrettably, became a confounding garble of twisted, choking inconsistencies that eventually threatened to wreck the foundation altogether. It got to the point where I couldn't tell which character was Gregor and which was Simon. They became as the same person and unrecognizable from their formerly established characters. I lost track of the story because the main characters abruptly were so muddied and odiously unlikable. It was as if the author himself forgot who was who in his literary madness. Not only did the story turn to something painfully unreadable but the situations the couple's bad choices entangled them in resembled an abyss that got deeper, darker, and far less amusing than I could tolerate. The characters committed horrible atrocities that were presented in a way that ultimately condoned their behavior. Similar to another "holobiont"* set of books I recently read and was faintly appalled by**, the degeneration of values and lack of respect for life (human and plant alike) depicted at the end of this story all but crumbled to incomprehensibility, leaving me cold and filled with regrets for what could have been a brilliant first novel. The initial half was so enjoyable and fun. While I wouldn't have called this outright horror, it had moments of dread that I relished in context with all the plant concepts. I'm not entirely certain if it was an inexperienced author that was to blame for the crimes committed in the writing of the second portion of this tome, or an editor who let far too many mistakes creep in that went unrevised--probably both of these in combination. A third alternative is that this is simply the unimaginable (to me), new way books are written, and I'm just too old to appreciate it. Sigh. 

*Various symbiotic organisms joined as an ecological unit--read more about this on Wikipedia if you're interested. 

**The Southern Reach Series by Jeff VanderMeer. 

Despite my regrets for what might have been, I must say, what a lovely cover. I adore it!  Bravo, Julia Lloyd! 

To go along with the theme of this review, here's a botanical art project I recently finished for my daughter's birthday.

"Autumn…Where Nature and Imagination Merge"

(rendered in coloring pencil)

© Karen Wiesner (all rights reserved)

 Karen Wiesner is an award-winning, multi-genre author of 156 titles and 16 series. 

Visit Karen here: https://www.writers-exchange.com/Karen-Wiesner/


Friday, October 16, 2026

Toddler Tycoons or {Put This One on Your TBR List}: Review of Wildwood Dancing Series by Juliet Marillier by Karen S. Wiesner

 

Toddler Tycoons or {Put This One on Your TBR List}: Review of Wildwood Dancing Series by Juliet Marillier

by Karen S. Wiesner

 

Beware spoilers!

 

The entertainment industry these days seems to be populated with toddler tycoons. The attention spans of those making the choices about what the population will be allowed to read, watch, play, or listen to is on par with that of a toddler. At that age, children tend to have trouble focusing on one thing for long, and they're forever abandoning the "old" in favor of something new that will only temporarily hold their interest. To add insult to injury, these "toddlers" are looking for profit above all. If it's not there in sufficient quantities, it doesn't matter how good the material is. Some of the most valuable works of art have been abandoned for little more justification than that it's the belief of some toddler tycoon that it wasn't profitable enough to warrant continuance. Many of us who enjoy these entertainments have become wary about investing ourselves and our money in anything that reaches into series territory for fear that the work will be dumped unceremoniously at any point. In the process, satisfactory resolution to the material may never be obtainable.

 

 

It's unfortunate that my first attempt at jumping into author Juliet Marillier's body of work was met with this situation. It was 2023 that I read The Bridei Chronicles, her third series of historical fantasy novels. I'd purchased them as hardcovers. In this set of stories, Bridei is sent to be educated by Broichan, a druid, in the sixth century (depicting King Bridei I of the Picts). Before long, Bridei finds a baby of the Good Folk, whom he names Tuala. The two grow up together. Even as they fall in love, their union calls them to very different destinies. How they reconcile themselves to their fates is developed throughout the series. I reached the end of the third book and realized there were no more stories forthcoming, despite that there were unresolved threads in the series! I was appalled. At that time, Marillier had spoken of the publisher for the work deciding not to continue it and hoping, for the most part, that she'd done an adequate job of tying up loose ends. I wasn't satisfied with the way things ended. I left the series very disappointed, though I admit I was impressed with the writing as a whole. Characters, conflicts, settings, relationships were all fantastically and beautifully rendered.

 

Concerned about embarking on another series that could be forsaken by the publisher, I instead tried one of Marillier's rare single titles. My review of Heart's Blood was posted on the Alien Romances Blog in early 2024 here: https://aliendjinnromances.blogspot.com/2024/01/karen-s-wiesner-put-this-one-on-your_0103362056.html. I did enjoy it immensely but wasn't willing to invest in another series, which is what the author specializes in.

 

In mid-2026, the author came up on my library app, and I recalled how much enjoyed her approach. Marillier roots her fantasy elements into historical fact in an intriguing way. I remembered vividly that her writing style was timeless, beautifully lush and elaborate, and I decided to try another of her series. Ebooks for her Wildwood Dancing Series were immediately available (the only ones that were) so I checked them out.

 

 

Wildwood Dancing, Book 1, is a fascinating reinvention of the Brothers Grimm's The Twelve Dancing Princesses, though I feel The Frog Prince might have been an inspiration as well, as the author didn't marry herself fully to either fairy tale. In this series, there are only five sisters and the main character "princess" (Jena) isn't spoiled. The frog is her close friend whom she values. In addition to these influences, this particular story also plays with 16th-century Transylvania folk legends about Dracula, which injected an awesome angle into what might have otherwise been a straightforward story. Jena is the point of view character, the second oldest daughter of a wealthy merchant. As one of five daughters, ages five to seventeen, Jena and her sisters enter a portal in the woods surrounding their castle to the Other Kingdom every full moon. There, they dance and mingle with magical creatures. When their father falls ill and has to recover for the winter on the coast, Jena and her oldest sister are left in charge with his merchant partner as well with their father's relative. In their childhood, Jena and her cousins Costi and Cezar were tricked by a magical creature. Costi was lost to them, and Cezar never forgot. Ever after, he's sought revenge. Each visit through the portal brings the sisters back to a deteriorating home situation, as Cezar vies more and more power.

 

These stories are cited to be young adult stories targeting 12 to 15 year olds. I'm not sure there are many in that age range these days that would choose something this complex, but the tales are certainly age-appropriate. Adults who are interested in the story themes should feel free to indulge, as I'm convinced the pair are suited just as well or possibly more so to and for adult readers.

 

 

Cybele's Secret, Book 2 of the Wildwood Dancing Series, features Paula, the fourth sister of five and a scholar. It's been six years since the events in the first story. Within the first couple hundred pages, the author finally decides to get caught up with events from the last installment, and we see a happily ever after for Jena and Iulia, while the eldest sister Tati, who'd chosen to remain in the Other Kingdom with her love Sorrow, is presumed to be happy with her choices. Little sister Stela is now eleven.

 

In Cybele's Secret, Paula has accompanied her father on a business trip to Istanbul. They're on the hunt for the statue of the goddess Cybele. The setting provides a rich tapestry for the events of this story, with a compelling Robert Langdon urgency to them, as the quest for ancient artifacts and the secrets associated with them become more and more dangerous. There's a connection between this plot thread and events from the first book with dreams Paula has of her sister Tati. It is within those dreams that Paula learns the eldest sister was trapped beyond the portal because of her decision to stay with Sorrow, who can't leave the Other Kingdom. The fairy queen won't allow Tati to leave either without payment in the form of a dangerous quest undertaking to  gain favor with the fairies. Within Cybele's Secret, the gentle love story between Paula and her bodyguard was wonderfully drawn. Paula herself was a formidable and worthy heroine, as her sister Jena was before her, displaying wisdom and tenacity beyond her years.

 

Both books started a little slowly as the author set up locations, characters, backgrounds, and conflicts. For the first couple hundred pages, nothing serious seemed to be happening and there was little suspense other than that of (in Book 1) five young girls being put into positions of power in a time period where women were largely ignored and overlooked as intelligent beings. In Book 2, Paula also faced too many people who underestimated her and tried to cram her into their narrow definitions of what a female her age should be. The situation with the frog in Wildwood Dancing was predictable but including "Night People" (vampires), fairies, and other creatures that inhabit the Other Kingdom added a unique, welcome twist to the plots of both stories.

 

From the first book, I assumed each sister would get her own story, but it was clear in the early part of Book 2 that the author tried to tell several of the sisters' stories already, in brief summaries instead of full narratives. Perhaps Marillier anticipated that what she was planning as a series could be cut off before she could complete them all. The author spoke of intending to write Stela's story, but, when the publisher asked her to be done with Wildwood Dancing Series, advising she start a new one, Marillier let go of the idea of a larger series and moved on to something different.

 

Alas, any possibility of a trilogy has been tabled, once again, by the toddler tycoon of the entertainment industry. Sigh. How is it I always end up choosing the truncated series by this author? Surely not all her series can end abruptly with readers longing for more of the world and its characters and feeling disappointment that there will be no continuation? Luckily, Wildwood Dancing is a standalone series with both books telling a full, encapsulated tale within its own installment. While I might want Stela's story, I knew in advance of finishing my reading of Book 2 that it wasn't a possibility.

 

While I would love to read all of Marillier's series, I continue to be wary about investing time and money only to find that a series was left unresolved because of toddler tycoon syndrome. I imagine the author has also had a lot of disappointments in this regard over the years as she writes for a fickle entity that favors new and profitable over wonderful and worthy. (Not to imply that Marillier doesn't regularly provide all four of those aspects in her wonderful work.) As such, I'll be checking her ebooks or audiobooks out from the library (app) prior to considering making a purchase. This will allow me to ensure I haven't inadvertently purchased expensive books in a series that will never be finished.

 

Juliet Marillier is an author that any fan of history and fantasy, especially when combined, is sure to love. All of these series are recommended with the reservation that you'll deserve more in the case of some of them--more that some toddler tycoon huckster has deprived you of for poor reasons. However, this is balanced by the fact that you'll want more from this author anyway. Her books are addictive and her writing talent is well-worth your attention. 

Karen Wiesner is an award-winning, multi-genre author of 156 titles and 16 series. 

Visit Karen here: https://www.writers-exchange.com/Karen-Wiesner/


Friday, October 02, 2026

{Put This One on Your TBR List} Book Review: Three Black Lantern Publishing Novels by Caitlin Starling by Karen S. Wiesner

 

{Put This One on Your TBR List} Book Review:

Three Black Lantern Publishing Novels by Caitlin Starling

by Karen S. Wiesner

 

Beware spoilers!

 

In the past, I've reviewed several other offerings from Caitlin Starling on this blog. Do a search of her name to find them, if you're interested. My reviews of this author's work tend to run the gamut in terms of whether I enjoy the material or not. This particular review of three separate books highlights the same situation.

 

Starling's last big release was The Graceview Patient in late 2025, so I went looking for anything new from her. I discovered she has a brand new horror coming out from St. Martin's Press in October 2026 called Milkteeth about a vampire broodmother, which should be interesting. This upcoming book is touted on the author's website, as well as the publisher's, and it's already available for preorder in multiple formats on distributor websites. In the process of discovering this welcome news, I stumbled upon several "new" books with Starling's name on them that are all published by Black Lantern Publishing instead of the big publisher(s) most of her other publicized books are released by.

 

I spent far too much time trying to find out more about Black Lantern Publishing (not to be confused with Black Lantern Books, which is a completely different thing) and Starling's association with them. All I could dig up was that Black Lantern Publishing is/was(?) an online art and literary journal which publishes macabre offerings--a perfect fit for Starling. In any case, they're listed as the publisher for three Starling books I came upon that I'd never heard of before and that are only published as ebooks (that I've been able to ascertain anyway) and not reliably available. For instance, one of them isn't for sale at all from Amazon, for a reason I couldn't locate. I guess the background behind these three books will remain a mystery because the author hasn't put any of them on her personal website (as of this writing in June 2026). Maybe they're old books that her current, big publisher has allowed to be published or reissued by a small press as long as she doesn't put or promote them with her other sanctioned work released by them. I don't know. But it's frustrating not to be able to find more about the origin of these particular stories. Anyway, given that, in general, I'm a fan of this author, I bought all three at once.

 

 

The first one I read, Beneath Winter Lake, was purchased from Apple Media Services. In this horror novel released December 2025, a climatologist is studying Winter Lake in Hawthorn's Rest when the lake suddenly freezes solid and the settlement that drowned more than a century ago rises to the surface. The dead from the village start taking the current townsfolk that share its ancestry. Apparently, this situation reoccurs every 40 years.

 

There was nothing particularly wrong with this book--technically it was decently written yet somehow everything about it felt generic to me. Nothing resonated with me, not characters, plot, nor setting. I also didn't find it scary.

 

 

The second, The Deadlight Motel, is an "eldritch horror" novel and was also published in December 2025 by Black Lantern Publishing. I got it from Amazon as a Kindle ebook (I don't think print or audio editions are available for it). In this (again, not at all frightening) story, a motel that's treated almost like it's human appears only to those who hide guilty secrets and it feeds on them.

 

I had the same problem with this story as the first. I call these "eh" books--not badly written but essentially generic. As with Beneath Winter Lake, my emotional involvement in the story never really kicked in.

 

Both Beneath Winter Lake and The Deadlight Motel did have what could be considered a mutual saving grace (that didn't actually make them easier to read for me, but hey) that is a Caitlin Starling trademark: Both stories were told with a unique twist. However, the problem for me is that every story I read by this author has a unique twist, and I went into reading both of these expecting that right from the beginning so, in truth, I guessed what each twist would be almost exactly from the very first chapters. Readers who haven't read Starling's work before probably wouldn't have guessed the endings right from the start so there's a potential for more enjoyment than I experienced with either of them.

 

 

The third, The Uncrowned, was a political fantasy novel and was published in April 2026 by Black Lantern Publishing. I got it from Amazon as a Kindle ebook (again, I couldn't find a print or audio edition anywhere). This story had an intriguing premise: On the day of his coronation, the crown prince refuses the throne because he's discovered that, within the empire, an entire group of people and their way of life have essentially been erased from history. He intends to right that wrong. But he quickly learns that there's much, much more that he doesn't know and the betrayal and deception go deeper than he originally believed--and when the truth resurfaces, the empire will never again be the same.

 

I was anticipating the worst, based on my previous two experiences. However, I was gratefully rewarded with the promise of intrigue and the seeds of compelling settings, plot, and characters that could have been a little better drawn. For instance, instead of three-dimensional, Prince Aldric Vane and his aunt were both two-dimensional and, weirdly, in exactly the same way. (I think anyone who reads this story will understand what I mean by that, since the two characters are like gender-opposite reflections of each other.) The secondary characters were, at best, one-dimensional.

 

As for setting and plot, both were oddly two-dimensional in that readers were given the starkest bare bones of the land the tale is set in, and the conflict that prompted the story had no more and no less than what was required to convey the story. At no point were readers allowed to discover what incited the empire's actions in essentially wiping out the Telvari community the way it did. The characters themselves didn't show the slightest curiosity about that either, which struck me as wrong and unrealistic. It seemed as if they accepted the situation, like it was a done deal, yet here they were single-mindedly involved in a legal battle to correct something that couldn't really ever be made right. Readers were never given the reasons behind all this, nor were the characters' motivations adequately portrayed. They had a goal and those actions took the place of their feelings entirely. Again, this gave them a flat quality that could have instead been heart-rending if only they'd been developed to the fullest.

 

My biggest problem with the story was that the author wrote it so leanly that every aspect became ravenous for fleshing out. Why would Starling do it this way? I can't fathom. Every single path was a thin, straight line with just a little detail pointing behind to the past, scant focus ahead to consequences, and the present story hogging the whole of the focus. As a result, countless opportunities for richness and depth were squandered. As a reader, I would have given anything for more information and to have gotten the entire tale developed three-dimensionally. It might have been a saga that couldn't be put down. It might have spanned ages in a world so vibrant, readers could see, taste, and smell it all as if they were really there. The plots might have carried much more weight and complexity that would have given them the gravitas they deserved. Fully-fleshed out characters could easily have vied for wider attention from the audience, allowing readers to truly root for them and share every tear shed and every bit of joy in comingled triumph. All of these elements hung there, strangled, just waiting for the breath of life to fulfill them. Instead, we got razor-sharp, cardboard quality. I longed for so much more. Yet the author could still expand into sequels in so many different directions--if she and her publisher were willing.

 

As is, The Uncrowned is compelling, but I'm ultimately saddened by the loss of something that was so close to moving and capturing me wholly. That said, the ending was nevertheless satisfying for me (despite that I wanted loads more) and I enjoyed the unusual take. It was almost like an early John Grisham novel, only in a fantasy world setting. Every aspect of this story was written as if it was a lawyerly account, with all the behind-the-scenes and courtroom drama you could ever want. In other words, it was cold-blooded and logical, with no room for human frailty or fragility. That worked well here, even given the wasted opportunities for growth beyond the immediate scenario. Maybe some readers would have been put off by that, but I found the moral of the story was told perfectly from that unique, distanced perspective. I also think it was brilliant of the author to remove almost completely the "real life" that you and I know from the setting so the account could be less about comparing it to our world events and history and instead about seeing it on its own, with all the texture, ramifications and consequences that the subject material demanded. I would actually love to revisit these characters and the world they're set in, but I suspect that's not an option--directly due to the "mystery" I mentioned in the third paragraph of this review.

 

You might want to give the first two books reviewed here a pass unless you're new to the author. Honestly, though, all of them were $3, so under $10 for three ebooks is worthwhile. The Uncrowned was a steal at that price, lack of true depth notwithstanding. 

Karen Wiesner is an award-winning, multi-genre author of 156 titles and 16 series. 

Visit Karen here: https://www.writers-exchange.com/Karen-Wiesner/


Friday, September 25, 2026

{Put This One on Your TBR List} Review of The Halcyon Fairy Book by T. Kingfisher by Karen S. Wiesner

 

{Put This One on Your TBR List}

Review of The Halcyon Fairy Book by T. Kingfisher

by Karen S. Wiesner 

** THIS POST CONTAINS MY 300TH REVIEW FOR THE ALIEN ROMANCES BLOG! ** 

  Beware many, many spoilers! 

T. Kingfisher (the pen name of Ursula Vernon) is a versatile author, illustrator, and artist. The author did The Halcyon Fairy Book's artwork herself. On the copyright page, it says "Ursula Vernon's annotated fairy tales were originally posted to her blog between February 2012 and July 2013 with the exception of 'King of Love' which is original to this anthology. They have been lightly edited from their initial postings." Two of the stories she put on her blog couldn't be included in the book because they aren't yet in the public domain. From there, the author proceeds to tell us in the introduction about a certain writer who goes by two names that frequently can't sleep and so finds herself reading (and critiquing) fairy tales in the wee hours of the morn. I love how Kingfisher slightly twists the word "annotated", which normally means to add notes and comments to explain or criticize the text they're included with, to highlight the insane and strange behavior of characters in each story with her sarcastically witty and hilarious insights. Make no mistake, these fairy tales aren't the star of this particular show. No, Kingfisher's annotations are what make this anthology worth reading. 

It might interest you to learn that the first book of fairy tales to appear in English was "The Blue Fairy Book" by Andrew Lang in 1889 (gathered from such diverse sources as the Brothers Grimm, Arabian Nights, Norwegian folklore, and French tales). Fairy tales were (maybe rightly so, as you're about to discover, if you haven't already) considered harmful for young readers until that time. In 1894, "The Yellow Fairy Book" followed up on the first. Lang's retellings secured the value of fairy tales as treasured children's stories and sparked a dramatic shift in public perception. And now we come full circle: True to the last few decades of popular desire to twist everything wholesome into something disturbed, the varnish has been stripped off these old humdingers and we can once again enjoy(?) them as they were intended. 

Below are my reviews for all the stories in the first half of The Halcyon Fairy Book. Kingfisher also includes the entire anthology of Toad Words and Other Stories within the second half of this collection. Do a search by author or title on this blog to find my previously completed review of that. 

"The Blue Light": This retelling of the soldier and the tinderbox fairy tale has many different renderings, which Kingfisher imparts within her variation. In true Mystery Science Theater 3000 tradition, she injects amusing comments all throughout the text and leaves none of the other versions of this story anywhere to hide. I loved it. 

"The Master-maid": A prince is held captive by a giant who asks of him one impossible task each day. The Master-maid (whatever that is) is also a captive of the giant. Each day she tells the prince how to complete his task in her no-fail wisdom. They dream of marrying each other one day when they're free. When they do manage to escape together, the prince pouts and wants to go home to visit his rich, powerful daddy. The Master-maid warns him not to do this because it won't be long before he forgets all about her. And he does (though, in his defense, a troll is scheming to get him to forget). The Master-maid turns into an outright witch at that point, so incensed by losing her man that she decides to take her fury out on every other (rich) man that crosses her path. Her treachery turns against her eventually, but by then the prince has remembered her, and the two can get on with their happily ever after as planned. This story was long, tedious, and eye-rolling. I thought it would never end. I didn't really care after a certain point whether it ended happily. Kingfisher's razor-sharp wit was the saving point and winning element to this otherwise far-fetched, shocking, and unbelievable tale. 

"The Crystal Casket": This story is based on an Italian version of Snow White that doesn't have dwarfs but eagles and, in my opinion, is barely worth reading. If the tale was going for "drastically different than what everyone knows and loves", okay, maybe it's a winner. But as a good, strong story, this never really made it out of the gate. Good thing I was reading for the annotations. 

"The Wonderful Sheep": A mind-bogglingly strange rendition of, again, Snow White, only it's the king who wants his daughter's heart and life (but most of all her tongue). The youngest princess and a bunch of her servants and pets monkey and dog fight about who's going to get the dubious honor or sacrificing their three items in question for her. Suddenly, one after the other, the servants and pets are committing suicide right in front of her. (To prove what a stupid story this is, Princess Miranda does not have the reaction most people would have after this occurrence--which would be equivalent to being sent to a looney bin as soon as it was equinely possible to get her there.) Instead, she discovers that none of them has the right kind of tongue for the job of convincing her father that it's hers. In the end, she writes down the whole tragic testimony on the bark headstone of the grave she digs, you know, in case her murderous dad comes look for her and wonders what happened. Senselessly, she heads off into the forest, where she meets the king of sheep--

        Yeah, and on that insane note, it occurs to me that the author's comments are really the only logical responses to be had within these pages. This terrible story with a rotten king who fluctuates between spoiling his youngest daughter shamelessly and then wanting to chop her head off the next (along with a thoroughly unworthy, superficial princess) isn't worth your time. Kingfisher's commentary and finishing the story on a definitely-not-happy end note were the best parts of it. 

"The Wonderful Birch": In this Russian version of Cinderella, a witch schemes to turn the wife of a desirable man into a sheep. She succeeds, but the daughter of the previously happy couple is determined to put things right--and this involves some magic that has her turned out so handsomely the prince himself can't resist her. The witch has a daughter of her own, a poor being that practically lives under the prince's table like little more than a dog, during an extended banquet. Repeatedly during this fest, the witch's daughter is injured. She's kicked so hard, bones break and she gets one of her eyes poked out by what one presumes must be a stiletto heel worn by a monstrous guest. (These partygoers seated at the VIP table must have some idea that the dogs have converged under them to eat the scraps, yet you can't help but wonder how heartless they must be. Who would kick a dog so hard, they break a bone, or poke out an eye in the process of punishing what they believe are canines just trying to get some sustenance below them?) Every time I think these insane fairy tales can't get worse or be more nonsensical, they can and they do. This one wasn't easy to read--and not just because so often cannibalism factors into these disturbing old fairy tales--though Kingfisher's annotations provided at least some comic relief from the full-on, escalating horror. 

"The Golden Apple Tree and the Nine Peahens": Someone's stealing the golden apples from the king's singular apple tree (a thing so unique, apparently it pollinates itself!). He sends his three sons, one at a time, to discover who the thief is. Only his youngest has any success in uncovering the truth. Not surprisingly, magic is afoot…and peahens. A bunch of them aren't what they seem and at least one of them can turn into a human girl so beautiful, the youngest prince (who is clearly not important enough to name) falls hopelessly in love with her, and her with him. This beauty claims more than once that the prince will never see her again if he doesn't do something that's required, but it's clear she and/or the laws of magic are very flexible about that because he's given numerous chances to get it right. In the meantime, a lot of people get murdered by him without so much as a trial. Brutal times, eh? This is one fairy tale I enjoyed a lot as a child, though, thanks to the retelling author's hilarious insights, I'm seeing so many freaky things I hadn't noticed before during my past readings.

          Unfortunately, this story didn't end where it should have. Instead, it took a turn for the why?. With a dragon riding a horse, the prince gaining brotherhood with a fish, a fox and a wolf, the tale descends into absolute ludicrousness. No part of the extension added anything useful or interesting to the previous wackiness. Kingfisher included a lot of spot-on commentary concerning the end of this piece. 

"The Deer Prince": A widower and a widow, with a daughter each, get married. The husband's daughter is pretty, the wife's ugly. The wife gets jealous, the husband is never home to notice his adorable kid being abused, and, as must always be the case in fairy tales, something outlandish happens that doesn't fit the situation at all. One night, there's a knock on the door and the wife orders her hideous daughter to answer it. There's a deer standing there. The daughter tries to beat it with a broom so it runs away. The next night, there's again a knock, and now the cute daughter answers it. Instead of driving the deer off, she talks to it. This stag wants her to hop on his back and come away with him, where they can "enjoy" (wink wink, nudge nudge) the forest together. Isn't there a cautionary saying about following a stranger who promises candy inside his love van? Nevertheless, she hops on and the stag bounds off to his magic-addled castle. He warns her not to go into three of the doors within the place before he disappears. Of course he knows as well as the reader does that she'll be snooping before a few days have passed. And she does. He clearly makes such a big deal about the doors, we realize in retrospect, because he's hoping she'll be a Nosy Nancy. It's the only way to break the enchantment that's been placed on the castle and over himself.

     Alas, happily-ever-after might have ensued if any of these old fairy-tale authors knew when to quit. Instead, the stupid once-a-stag prince asks his bride if she wants her stepmother and sister to visit them. (Not sure what happened to her not-so-dear-old-dad.) While it's very true that the story was disappointingly resolved without any conflict at all with Door #3 leading to wedded bliss, what came after the prince's total lack of forethought was even worse--though, thankfully, Kingfisher's enjoyable commentary explained merrily why she's not a fan of traditional fairy-tale endings. 

"Two Cinderellas": So named because Kingfisher decided to give us two, short, Cinderella-esque tales filled to bursting with reasons for her to take issue with events.

The first one is uproariously titled "Little Saddleslut"! The original author didn't bother pulling any punches. He got right into the action with this one: A mom is spinning flax with her three daughters and the two older tots decide to play a homicidal game. Whoever's spindle falls gets murdered and eaten by the others. Again with the cannibalism? Someone please tell me why all these "bedtime tales" always end up with someone getting eaten? The youngest daughter prudently begs off on partaking and uses magic to get revenge for her beloved mother. In the process, she loses a shoe, the king's son finds it, and wants to marry only the one who fits in it. He does, they have a kid, and Little Saddleslut stupidly leaves her bloodthirsty sisters alone with the princess. Little Saddlemoron might have been a better name for her! But, in the end, everything turns out fine…if you consider the evil sisters being hacked to pieces fine. Yeah, maybe it's a fitting ending for these bad daughters, and I guess I should just be grateful they weren't put in a stew and eaten by the whole kingdom.

       Next up is "Conkiajgharuna, the Little Rag Girl" (the first, unpronounceable word actually means "little rag girl"). Wife dies, husband remarries a shrew (who has her own daughter) to tend his orphan daughter. Shrew hates her new husband's kid and proves to be a witch who curses the little girl* to take a loaf of bread, eat of it, share it with everyone she meets, but somehow has to bring it home whole every night. Couldn't Conk just buy or bake a new loaf to bring home? I guess somehow the witch would know the difference. A cow (also, apparently, a witch with magic powers) tries to help Conk by letting her siphon butter and honey from its horns. Cool! Only now the little ragamuffin gets fat, and the stepmother gets wise to Conk's sidestepping. Time to raise the stakes of impossible cruelty. Conk finds herself in the presence of an ogress who values quick thinkers. Again, the little girl goes home with a prize that night, and her stepmother is fit to burst at being thwarted. She figures maybe her own daughter could use some bovine and ogress time, too, but it doesn't go well for this girl and the stepwitch ends up trying to the kill the cow, who, as you might expect, isn't at all what it seems and instead does Conk another good turn at her end. From there, this turns into the Cinderella story with one twist. The stepwitch wants her own daughter to marry the king (not the prince), but her scheming runs afoul when Conk emerges from the place her bad mommy hid her in the throne room and announces the slipper belongs to her. She can prove it, too. I have to spoil this one for sheer stupidity: Yeah, Rag Girl becomes queen, happily-blah-blah-after, but the worst that happens isn't her stepmom being hacked to pieces or boiled into soup for the wedding feast. No, she just leaves with a "dry throat" of chagrin. Wow. I really couldn't make this stuff up if I tried.              

*If these old-world fairy tale writers are to be believed, all widowed men should be scared out of their braies about being preyed upon by witches (with daughters) looking to hook up with previously married men (who also have daughters) in order to abuse that man's only child. What the heck, man? 

"The Story of Log": A man and a woman want a child of their own so badly, they fashion one out of a log and dress it and rock it and…is anyone else thinking, "My very own log! Just what I always wanted. I will hug him and pet him and squeeze him and name him George"? Well, they called him Log. A few years later, the thing comes to life and goes on a killing spree with just his log arms-- No, no, no. Don't worry! Log is a kind and gentle log person who goes on to save the country from a vile sun, moon, and dawn thief. He's apparently not a log for brains, but he is a shapeshifter--he's able to change himself from a human into firewood on a whim. You wouldn't think that would be terribly useful in your day to day, but it actually is here. According to Kingfisher, you'll be forgiven for singing a rousing rendition of "The Log Song" by Ren & Stimpy while you're reading this whackadoodle of a story. 

"Tatterhood": Let me sum up the moral of this story: A queen who thinks being a good mother is either spoiling someone rotten or bossing him or her around isn't fit to be anything but the imperious queen she is. Let's leave it at that. If only the sadist storytelling had taken that good advice. But no, he had to go and write the whole, sorry tale that culminates in "an ugly hussy" named Tatterhood toting "a severed head under one arm, riding her war goat, beating the crap out of people with a wooden spoon" (as only Kingfisher could describe it). 

"The Seven Doves": Based on an Italian fairy tale of "bros turned into birds" and their poor sister who intends to save them from their (maybe well-deserved) fate, this one starts with seven boys born in seven years to one mother. This hockey team decides they can't bear another male child entering their household. They threaten their poor, fertile mother and leave home until such a time as she can produce a female sibling for them. (Yeah, you read that right.) Somehow these lugheads think she has a choice. I think it's clear this story isn't going anywhere good. Would you believe me if I told you cannibalism may be involved? Of course you would. It only makes sense at this point. 

"The King of Love": A man with three daughters (it's always three; why is it always three?) takes the youngest with him to pick wild herbs. She pulls up what seems to be a fine radish but is actually a door that reveals a green bird bathing in a pan of milk. Said bird dries himself and becomes a gorgeous specimen of human hunk. Wait a minute, what? The punishment for the crime of picking a radish-door is apparently that this daughter has to become the wife of this hunk. The dad is paid off but encouraged to drop in anytime. The other two sisters decide to figure out what in all that's holy is going on here with the radish-door, milky-bird-shapeshifting hunk their dad told them about. The sisters persuade their youngest sibling to do what the hunk has asked her to promise not to do--find out who he is. Ready to guess his name? (Hint: It's in the title!) Insert groan, or some other strange noise here. As Kingfisher says, "Some people call him Maurice." The hunk promptly disappears but not for long as the youngest keeps conjuring him back and eventually saves him from an ogress's curse. Somehow, this one has a happy ending--unless by some misfortune you've read the wrong version of it and the poor girl is forced to wear a pair of iron shoes until they wear out. Only then can she find her husband. Hey, don't say you weren't warned of what can happen when you try to read these fairy-tale doozies. 

~*~ 

I'm not sure what prompted the title of The Halcyon Fairy Book. What was the author going for? The word "halcyon" as an adjective means "denoting a time period that was idyllically happy and peaceful". None of these stories are happy let alone peaceful. I can only conclude Kingfisher was being sarcastically true to form, if the title has anything to do with that. Alternately, the noun version of the word refers to a tropical Asian or African kingfisher or a mythical bird said to breed (and charm the wind and waves into a state of calm) in a floating nest at sea during the winter solstice. Here's an image of a halcyon: 


 

Given the cover art and her pen name, maybe the bird itself--real or myth--was what the author was going for. Only a few of the stories actually included enchanted (or otherwise) birds. On that uncertain note, I'll say, ahh whatever. 

To conclude this review that I had a rollicking good time producing, if you like your fairy-tales roasted comedic style, you'll love every last one of T. Kingfisher's retellings of particularly bone-headed fairy tales that were so badly told that they had almost no right to be published in the first place. 

Karen Wiesner is an award-winning, multi-genre author of 156 titles and 16 series. 

Visit Karen here: https://www.writers-exchange.com/Karen-Wiesner/