Videogame Review: Colonial-style Supernatural Setting Within
GreedFall and GreedFall: The Dying World
by Karen S. Wiesner

When I heard there was a supernatural videogame with an early eighteenth century-styled setting coming out, I was excited about the prospect. GreedFall was released in 2019. The title may be a play on the idea of "landfall" and the greed of the settlers, explorers, mercenaries, and treasure hunters who discover the remote island paradise. It might also speak of the fall of a civilization and a way of life, and the greed of those who take what they want, regardless of the consequences. In this story, the indigenous locals aren't sure what to make of these "colonial forces" spreading through their lands. The Teer Fradee tribes have a bond with the earth, which has gifted them with powerful, mystical creatures that protect them as well as given them unique abilities. Since the invasion of their lands, the natives have had to deal with countless foreign nations and factions that are competing to conquer, claim, and colonize what they dub a "new" land. To the Teer Fradee, the land is ancient and it belongs to them. Some tribes are willing to share to keep the peace. Others aren't and will fight to keep what's theirs.
If any of this sounds familiar to you, you're not far off. Yes, this is a fictionalized account, but there's no disguising the blatant connotations to America's history. You play a noble merchant traveling to the island to serve as your cousin--the Prince's--legate. In the process, you're also hoping to find a cure for a mysterious illness that plagues the homeland and seems connected with the settlement of the island. Diplomacy is required with the natives along with all the factions that are attempting to establish a presence in a world that's new to them. How you as the main character go about negotiating and bringing about peace in a time of severe unrest is fascinating. Through persuasion, combat, alliances, or stealth, your decisions directly influence the outcome of countless lives and the manner of existence for all. It is entirely possible, though difficult, to unite all the factions and the natives and to learn to live together in present and future equanimity between all the island inhabitants.
I enjoyed this game immensely on its own fictional merits as well as the prospect of (at least mildly) seeing both sides of an incredibly volatile, real-life event. It's difficult to imagine how the pilgrims and natives were able to sit down to a three-day feast in celebration of the harvest and their newfound accord. I think GreedFall developers deliberately tried not to choose sides, thereby allowing the player to experience each perspective unbiased--or as much as that is possible, especially from the distance of hundreds of years. The main character has been given a direct connection to the natives in the form of a secret that's been withheld from him by his noble family. This forced him or her (the character is fully customizable by the player, an aspect that's at the top of my wishes when it comes to playing a videogame) to have an open-minded approach. While the subject matter was thinly veiled, the story was just deep enough to be thought-provoking and moving.
Gameplay was fairly easy with an emphasis on the excitement of discovery in an open-world exploration range along with ensuring that relationships were developed with your companions, each of them belonging to one of the newly established factions on and a native of the island. I will say that the companion relationships were tricky. You were given one chance to make the right dialogue choices. If you didn't, you risked making an enemy instead of a friend, alienating the person's entire faction, and if your interest was more amorous, you'd wreck your chance at romance by uttering one ill-advised statement. The game also forced you to make numerous saves in case you said or did anything wrong. If you wanted a hundred percent loyalty from all the companions and their individual factions, as I did (and have gotten every playthrough), you're required to think ahead and plan out the best manner to advance in every situation. There's one quest I've always failed because I haven't figured out the right strategy and order to complete it in. Needless to say, that's mildly frustrating for a completionist like me, though I have gotten a hundred percent of the achievements for the game anyway. Beyond that, the only issue I really have is that, when playing on easy, the combat is exactly that--easy--except at the end, in the final boss battle, where you're suddenly all on your own, your friends left behind to protect your flank alongside their factions (which you've proven loyalty to and so these are the ones loyal to you), and the combat suddenly becomes much harder. It should have been more balanced throughout the game. But that’s not a major complaint, more of an observation. Replay value is very high with GreedFall. I've finished it quite a few times, changing things up a little here and there with each new character so I can experience new facets.

A lot of players wanted to know more about the natives. As a result, GreedFall: The Dying World was released in 2026. This prequel was set three years before the original game. In this one, you play as a Teer Fradee native who's abducted by forces intent on colonizing the native's continent. In many cases, these forces are hostile and unwilling to make peace. In this perspective, we can see the harsh demands and impact colonization has on indigenous peoples. As before, your character is fully customizable, is imbued with mystic powers (you choose specifically which ones), and your choices influence every part of the game. Again, the character you're playing as is intended to be the peacemaker in this situation.
There is absolutely nothing veiled about this scenario. Still, the developers did attempt to make it possible to see all sides of the issue, though the slant and sympathy is naturally more toward the natives. I was interested in viewing the situation predominately from this angle. Any qualms I have with the game aren't with the subject matter, per se. I'm intrigued by the fresh vantage point. What I do take issue with is that the developers changed the combat style so it's turn-based rather than automatic. I hate turn-based. There's nothing intuitive about it. The only good thing about it is that there are settings in the main menu that allow you to sidestep any ill-effects of combat. In other words, you can't lose and you can't die. Before I realized this setting was there, I was constantly dying and couldn't figure out how the combat mechanics worked at all. So this at least allowed me to continue playing. I long for the previous game's satisfying combat style though. They didn't need to fix something that wasn't even broken, so I and a lot of other players aren't happy about it.
Additionally, there's a lot of stealth in this game that wasn't necessarily in the previous--more than I'm comfortable with. The other problem I'm having is that this prequel has interesting points of discovery and exploration, but it can be just plain boring. I love games where combat isn't the heart of everything. I want to explore and solve puzzles and have multiple avenues to discover a successful ending to a quest. However, I played through the first part of A Dying World and ended up taking a very long break from the game because there seems to be little or nothing by way of urgency or even a clue what the stakes are for failing in any quest. Being in the initial part of the game, the companions don't seem particularly memorable or interesting to me either. I do intend to go back soon and try to finish the game.
I highly recommend GreedFall and, to a lesser degree, GreedFall: The Dying World.

Given that it's the Thanksgiving season as I'm writing this and that the GreedFall games are set during a kind of fictional colonial period, I find myself thinking about that very first Thanksgiving and all that had to happen to make the differing "factions" come together the way they did. Seeing history from the viewpoint of all involved gives me a greater appreciation for peacemakers. On July 20, 1919, George Clemenceau--who knew life in the trenches as well as life at the top as a statesman and prime minister--said, "It is far easier to make war than peace." All war takes is an action carried out with little or no advance thought. Peace requires patience, open-mindedness and empathy, discomfort and tact in broaching sensitive subjects, and a willingness to stop and think long enough to analyze someone else's side of an issue along with your own. Without thought and respectful dialogue, intelligent reasoning accompanied by compromise that benefits both parties amity can never be achieved. The brave souls of peacemakers willingly undertake the forging of alliances with consequences that will resonate for centuries. Blessed are the peacemakers, indeed.
If you're interested, you can find my walkthrough of the original GreedFall here (you may have to cut and paste the link into your browser):
Karen Wiesner is an award-winning, multi-genre author of 156 titles and 16 series. Visit her website here: https://www.writers-exchange.com/Karen-Wiesner/
