Thursday, November 19, 2026

Billionaire Solipsists

Cory Doctorow's latest LOCUS column starts with a meditation on Amazon's draconian treatment of its drivers, which includes schedules too rigid to allow for restroom breaks:

Everybody Pees

Not only that, Amazon severely penalizes drivers caught with urine receptacles in their vans. Doctorow details this treatment of employees as support for his "hypothesis that billionaires don’t really believe that other people are real." He maintains that "billionaire solipsism" arises inevitably from the "fact of dealing with people as mass statistical abstractions." Viewing reality through this lens "turns the majority of the world’s other humans into phantasms, defective bots."

Doctorow links this attitude to the rapidly spreading prevalence of AI systems in a variety of transactions that used to require human-to-human contact. If one thinks other people aren't real, "it’s easy to believe that they can be swapped out for chatbots." Doctorow suggests that tycoons such as Mark Zuckerberg already see their customers as just "balky" chatbots. According to Doctorow, "attaining oligarch status is incompatible with viewing other people as real."

Must we accept this pessimistic premise? Do oligarchs in general, and particularly billionaires, inevitably devolve into solipsistic sociopaths? Or is solipsism a necessary condition for becoming ultra-wealthy? What about Bill and Melinda Gates? Warren Buffett? Their charitable activities seem to indicate caring about other people.

In fiction, fabulous wealth and sociopathy don't always go together. Johann Smith, protagonist of Robert Heinlein's I WILL FEAR NO EVIL, isn't explicitly stated to be a billionaire, but the way he tosses around sums in the million-dollar range implies he is. Although ruthless in business, he's portrayed as having a deep capacity for friendship and love. The "In Death" futuristic mystery series by J. D. Robb features Roarke, one of the richest people on Earth circa 2060, if not THE richest. A former thief and con artist, after amassing his fabulous wealth he went straight and thereafter married a New York City homicide detective. He has always had a sound moral core despite his criminal background, and as a tycoon he lavishes money on charitable causes as well as helping individuals in need. Maybe amassing riches by their own efforts from humble beginnings influenced these characters to retain sympathy for the common folk? Although their authors don't say so, that premise seems plausible. Smith comes from a modest background, and Roarke started as a street thief, imbibing his principles from a mentor who rescued him from a horrific home situation.

Extravagant wealth may make it harder for a person to feel proper empathy for others -- easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than a rich man to attain the kingdom of Heaven, etc. -- but, I hope, not impossible.

Margaret L. Carter

Please explore love among the monsters at Carter's Crypt.

No comments:

Post a Comment